The Best Ice Cream in New York

The Best Ice Cream in New York

Want to savour nothing but the best ice cream in New York? There are tons of available options for you. You can check out some of the best ice creams in NYC’s hottest locations. New York City loves its ice cream. So much so, that there are innumerable joints and outlets in every block. If you are in the Big Apple, do not return without tasting the famous ice cream.

Best Ice Cream in New York - Top Picks

Here are some of the top choices with regard to the best ice cream in NYC:

1. Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery, New York (image courtesy: co-office.co)

Visit DUMBO and you will see why people love this joint so much. Hailed for serving the best ice cream in New York, this one has seasonal flavours. You will love the spread by owners Petrushka Bazin and Nick Larsen. They draw inspiration from Caribbean and Midwestern backgrounds along with Harlem. The husband-wife duo has been going strong for years. They create special combinations of ingredients in this Central Harlem outlet. A second location has come nearby at Hamilton Heights as well. There are always new flavors on offer here.

2. Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

Chinatown Ice Cream Factory, New York (image courtesy: giantrobot.media)

Looking for the best ice cream in NYC? You should not miss this one! Run by a family for more than four decades. The popular scoop ice cream joint offers various unique varieties. They include red bean, durian, pandan and other lesser-known delights. A neat joint, it is ideal for a walk through Chinatown. The same family also runs another branch at Essex Market. If you are at the Lower East Side, you can consider paying that branch a visit.

3. Eddie’s Sweet Shop

Eddie’s Sweet Shop, New York (image courtesy: parkertowers.com)

Nostalgia pervades the senses here. Eddie’s Sweet Shop in Forrest Hills is famous for its frozen delights. It has been there for 100 years and counting. The homemade simple ice cream is irresistible. Enjoy the malted milkshakes alongside.

Also Read: 12 Best Theatres in New York (NYC) for the Best Movie Experience

4. Ample Hills Creamery

Ample Hills Creamery, Chelsea (image courtesy: yelp.com)

Ample Hills Creamery has 11 spots in the Big Apple. There is one with a rooftop and lovely view. The flavors are delectable and unique. Children especially love the crunchy goodies available at the popular joint. Ooey Gooey is worth trying here. It serves up St. Louis-esque butter cake with creamy vanilla.

5. Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream

Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream, New York (image courtesy: architecturaldigest.com)

Nick Morgenstern has a flagship Greenwich Village parlor. He brings tons of new flavors each season. You will love the chocolate eggplant and olive oil mix. Other hits include pineapple salted egg yolk and jelly and Tahini. You may also like the cardamom lemon jam or toasted rice Yuzu swirl.

6. Sundaes and Cones

Sundaes and Cones, New York (image courtesy: foodnetwork.com)

There are tons of options available at this East Village landmark. You will love the charming ambience and flavors here. It offers ginger, black sesame, wasabi and many other delectable picks.

Also Read: 10 Unique Street Foods You Must Try While You are in New York

7. Malai Ice Cream

Malai Ice Cream, Brooklyn, NY (image courtesy: yelp.com)

Run by Pooja Bavishi, this joint lies at Cobble Hill. The store offers fascinating flavors like sweet milk and star anise. Others include rose and cinnamon roasted almonds along with the ginger root. Turkish coffee is also a favourite for patrons.

8. Mikey Likes It Ice Cream

Mikey Likes It Ice Cream, New York (image courtesy: villagepreservation.org)

A retro parlor with an interesting story, this one also draws crowds. Mike Cole had his aunt passing away after his release from prison. He found a homemade vanilla ice cream recipe while cleaning her apartment. This drove his new business idea; he started making hip-hop themed flavors of ice cream. Cole has already made a mark with Foxy Brown and other flavors. The former has mocha with sea salt caramel swirl and crushed chocolate wafer cookies. The ice creams come in cones, cups and even sandwiches.

9. Momofuku Milk Bar

Momofuku Milk Bar, New York (image courtesy: gastronomyblog.com)

The Momofuku Milk Bar owes its start to Christina Tosi. The winner of several James Beard Awards, she rustles up innovative flavors here. She started a bakery first in 2008 and now has nine locations. Corn flakes combined with milk and brown sugar here. They go into the machine with a little salt. The resultant frozen treat is icy and tangy.

Also Read: 20 Things to Know About Moving to New York

10. OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

OddFellows Ice Cream Co., Brooklyn, NY (image courtesy: nycgo.com)

The ice cream shop lies in Brooklyn and offers artisanal varieties. It comes with locally-sourced ingredients and additive-free ice cream. You can get in-house pasteurized stuff with 12 flavors. You will love the sundaes and banana splits here. The Mast Brothers hot fudge is a big draw or the Salted Caramel. You will also appreciate the Cotton Candy Cone. Top draws include Tahitian Vanilla, Neapolitan and Strawberry. You can also choose Foie Gras, Miso-Cherry, etc. Maple-Bacon-Pecan is another top draw.

11. Il Laboratorio del Gelato

Il Laboratorio del Gelato, New York (image courtesy: lauraperuchi.com)

The East Side store offers a lab-themed space for visitors. There are 300+ flavors on offer for customers. There are Chefs crafting newer flavors all day. The artisanal gelato star Jon Snyder is behind this one. He is the pioneer behind Ciao Bella Gelato. He started this outlet to continue his flavor experiments in the 1980s. You will find top picks like nutmeg, wasabi and white peppercorn. You can also check out sage and other flavors here.

12. Davey’s Ice Cream

Davey’s Ice Cream, Brooklyn, NY (image courtesy: daveysicecream.com)

Davey’s Ice Cream lies in the East Village with a vibrant ambience. The retro theme dominates this outlet above all else. It has a wooden counter and marble flooring. The flavors are contemporary. You will find Black Sesame with an Asian touch here. Other hits include the Whiskey Cinnamon Bun and booze-glazed pastries. They also offer the Ultra Babka with cinnamon bread and baked chocolate. You will love the blackberry swirl and customizable ice cream sandwiches. Everything you find in the menu is convertible into these treats. Banana splits and sundaes are chief draws for the retro crowd. Every batch is completely crafted in-house. The dairy comes from the Battenkill Valley Creamery nearby.

Also Read: 10 Best Nightclubs in New York for an Unforgettable Nightlife Experience

13. Emack & Bolio’s

Emack & Bolio’s, New York (image courtesy: wikimedia.org)

Bob Rook, a noted music attorney, set up this outlet in 1975. Beginning in Boston, it has since come to NYC. It is a place that is still popular with musicians and their coterie. Popular patrons include James Brown, U2, Aerosmith and more. The Upper West Side location draws a more diverse crowd today though. Yet, the hippy and infectious vibe remain. You will love the zero-hormone organic ingredients on offer. They cover 40+ flavors including S’Moreo, Trippin’ on Espresso, etc. 14. Chloe’s Soft Serve Fruit Co - They offer intriguing flavors for those who love frozen yogurt. Chloe Epstein runs this joint and offers treats without artificial ingredients. The banana base comes with dark chocolate and cacao. There are a total of fourteen seasonal options available here.

14. Chloe’s Soft Serve Fruit Co

Chloe’s Soft Serve Fruit Co, New York (image courtesy: toyou-fromscratch.com)

They offer intriguing flavors for those who love frozen yogurt. Chloe Epstein runs this joint and offers treats without artificial ingredients. The banana base comes with dark chocolate and cacao. There are a total of fourteen seasonal options available here.

If you are thinking of landing in New York anytime soon, make sure you plan your itinerary. Find studio apartments in New York for the length of your trip. Check distances to nearby attractions before booking.