Top 5 Places to Try Bagels in New York

From pastrami sandwiches to pizza dough, New York is known the world over for its iconic culinary offerings. Whether you’re in The Big Apple for business or pleasure, there’s nothing better than a genuine New York bagel to start your day, and with plenty of outlets around, it’s no wonder so many visitors choose to escape their furnished apartments of a morning and breakfast out. Boiled, baked and liberally coated with cream cheese, fish rashers and eggs, every bagel is unique and individually customised for some of the best takeout food available.

Here are a few of our favourite places to try bagel in New York:

  1. Orwasher’s bakery

An old-school artisan bakery, Orwasher’s is known for producing some of the best bagels in the Upper East Side. Using a high-tech steam oven rather than the classic boiling and baking method, every bagel comes out with a gorgeous glossy finish, ensuring that these beauties look as good as they taste. The wider menu is just as delectable, with a range of Jewish rye well befitting the historic kosher spot, not to mention European-style loaves and rustic wine bread made from the grapes of Long Island’s Channing Daughters Winery.

Orwashers Bagel New York
Address: 308 E 78th St., New York, 10075

Opening Timing: Mon-Sat 8am-7pm & Sun 9am-4pm

2. Tompkins Square Bagels

Situated in the heart of New York’s East Village district, this 25-seat café serves hand-rolled bagels, homemade lox, and excellent cheese, eggs and bacon. Though queues can be long, the wait is worth it – in addition to the classic boiled and baked formula, Tompkins Square Bagels also offers “old school” versions, smaller and chewier, as well as over twenty different flavours of cream cheese. What could be better of a morning than sipping coffee at a table, watching bakers boil rings of dough in the open kitchen, and tucking into a chocolate-chip cream cheese covered New York staple? With bagels like these, it’s no wonder some people travel in from neighbouring Brooklyn for this best-kept secret.

Tompkins Square Bagels New York / Image Credit: Go Dairy Free

Address: 165 Ave A, New York, 10009

Opening Timing: Open Every Day 6am-10pm

3. Bagel Oasis

With over fifty years of experience, this Queens-based bagel maker serves classic round bagels 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The hand-baked rounds come in all the familiar flavours, and are always generously stuffed, whatever your choice of filling. Cream cheese, lox and whitefish salad are always on the menu, and a huge range of serving platters makes Bagel Oasis ideal for sharing. They also deliver, so even apartments in the Upper East Side can enjoy fresh Queens bagels straight to the door.

Bagel Oasis, New York
Address: 18312 Horace Harding Expy, Queens, 11365

Opening Timing: Open 24/7

Price Range: $1-7. Platters $30+

4. Black Seed

This one’s a bit of a cheat to be honest, because the bagels at this popular chain are not strictly New York-style. The brainchild of two experienced restaurateurs, Black Seed bagels are more of a cross between a Big Apple bagel and a Montreal bagel, rounds that are chewy and dense, but are boiled in honey water and baked in a wood-fired oven. They are still delicious though, and are best enjoyed with Black Seed’s creative choice of toppings, like beet-cured lox, to really bring out that subtle sweet flavour. Multiple locations means that Manhattan Island is plenty furnished with Black Seed outlets, so you’re likely to run into one wherever your apartment. We’ve gone for the Tribeca one in Lower Manhattan for its proximity to the Hudson River boardwalk and World Trade Center plaza.

Black Seed New York
Address: 200 Vesey Street, New York, 10080

Open Timing: Mon-Fri 7am-5pm & Sat-Sun 9am-5pm

5. The Bagel Store

You may remember the culinary craze of 2016 that was the rainbow bagel – prismatic bagels furnished with Funfetti cream cheese, among other extravagant toppings. Turns out that was the work of this seminal Williamsburg bakery. Located in northwest Brooklyn, The Bagel Store’s highly creative menu also includes such goodies as pretzel bagels, cragels (croissant-bagel hybrids), rolls, wraps and platters, layered with elaborate cream cheese flavours like bacon or cannoli. And for those traditionalists, the sandwich selection is also excellent, making for a café-bakery that combines the best and the rest.

The Bagel Store New York
The Bagel Store New York
Address: 754 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn, 11211

Opening Timings: Open Every Day 7am-6pm

Price Range: $3-9

BONUS: Barney Greengrass

Okay, hear us out. This Upper West Side restaurant deli may be a little on the expensive side, but there is a very good reason why: its bagels are legendary! A madhouse at breakfast and brunch, the bagels here are just one component of gargantuan serving platters, topped with smoked fish (sturgeon or Nova Scotia salmon), your choice of eggs, cream cheese, and furnished liberally with salad garnish and a range of extra toppings. Cheaper options on the menu also include creamy egg salad, cold pink borscht and matzo-ball soup, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Step out from your apartment and head down to this staple of New York cuisine – we promise you won’t regret it!

Barney Greengrass
Barney Greengrass New York
Address: 541 Amsterdam Ave, New York, 10024

Opening Timing: Tue-Sun 8am-6pm

Price Range: $10-20. Cash only.

Elliott Troop

Elliott is our marketing executive with an MA in English Literature and works across both digital and content marketing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.